Look at this picture - what do you see (it might be difficult to make out as a still image)?
If someone can get a clearer picture of this please post it.
This is a picture of when Mohinder first went into Sylar's apartment. Notice what the camera is focusing on.
It's a mirror. The camera focuses on that mirror for a couple seconds deliberately.
Notice the image in the mirror. It's Mohinder - but he's upside down.
This is definately a clue indicating that Mohinder's thinking is all wrong.
Everyone's thinking about Sylar is all wrong (yes even me) - completely upside down.
Think about that for a while. I'll post an updated PART II later.